Business Advice

Vacation Rental Repeat Guests: How to Turn Past Stays Into Direct Bookings

A practical guide to turning past guests into direct repeat bookings, with timing, a simple outreach email, and the OTA rules to keep in mind.

Vacation Rental Repeat Guests: How to Turn Past Stays Into Direct Bookings

A guest stays at one of your properties, has a great week, and leaves a five-star review. Next year they want to come back. They open the Airbnb app, find the same house, and book it again. You get the guest back, and you pay the OTA fee again on someone who already knows your property, your team, and your town.

Vacation rental repeat guests are some of the most valuable bookings a management company gets. They already trust you, they need less hand-holding, and they're more likely to treat the property well. The problem is that most of them drift back to whatever channel they used the first time, simply out of habit. This guide covers how to change that: who you can actually reach, when to reach them, what to send, and how to tell whether it's working.

Why Vacation Rental Repeat Guests Drift Back to the OTAs

Most repeat guests aren't choosing an OTA over you. They just aren't thinking about you at all when they start planning. A few things work against you:

  • The app is already on their phone. Their past trip, saved payment method, and the listing itself are a tap away.
  • Nobody reminded them you have a website. If the only messages a guest got from you were check-in instructions and a review request, your site never came up.
  • Someone else got there first. OTAs send their own reminders and inspiration emails year-round. If you wait until spring to reach out, the OTA has had months of head start.
  • Booking direct feels like more work. If your site is slow, hard to use on a phone, or doesn't show real availability, guests go back to what's easy.

The cost adds up. As of October 27, 2025, Airbnb charges PMS-connected property managers a 15.5% host-only fee per booking. On a $2,500 week, that's $387.50. A guest who comes back for five summers in a row through Airbnb costs nearly $2,000 in fees for a relationship you built.

Who Can You Actually Contact?

This is the part many repeat-guest strategies skip, and it matters. You can't market to every past guest the same way.

Guests who booked direct

These are your core list. If a guest booked through your own website or by phone, and they agreed to hear from you when they booked, you can follow up with them about future stays. Make sure your booking flow includes a clear opt-in for marketing emails, and honor unsubscribes.

Guests who booked through an OTA

Be careful here. Airbnb's policies restrict using guest contact information from an Airbnb reservation for marketing outside the platform, and other OTAs have their own rules. Read the current terms for each channel you list on before you contact any OTA guest outside the platform. Breaking those rules can put your listings at risk.

The practical takeaway: your direct-booking list is the asset. Every guest who books direct once is a guest you can invite back directly. That's one more reason to make your own website easy to book on in the first place.

When to Reach Vacation Rental Repeat Guests

Timing does a lot of the work. A good message sent at the wrong time gets ignored.

  • Over the holidays (late November through early January). Families are together and often start talking about next summer's trip. A short note in December puts your property in that conversation.
  • Before your peak weeks fill. If your best summer weeks usually book by February or March, reach repeat guests in January so they get first pick.
  • Around the anniversary of their stay. A note a few months before the same week they stayed last year is personal and well-timed.
  • Soon after checkout. A thank-you within a week or two, with a mention that next year's calendar is open, catches guests while the trip is still fresh.

You don't need all four. Pick the one or two that fit your market and do them every year.

What to Send: A Simple Repeat Guest Email

The best repeat-guest emails are short and personal. They read like a note from the office, not a promotion. Here's a structure that works:

  1. Thank them by name and mention the property. "Thanks again for staying at Sea Oats last July" lands better than a generic greeting.
  2. Tell them next year is open. Let them know the calendar is available and when their week tends to book up.
  3. Link straight to the property on your site. Not your homepage. The specific listing, with availability for their dates if you can.
  4. Offer to hold their week. If you can hold the same dates for a few days, say so. People like knowing their week is still there, and it gives them a reason to decide now.
  5. Add a returning-guest perk if it makes sense. Early check-in, a waived fee, or a small discount for booking direct. Keep it simple and make sure it fits your owner agreements.
  6. Sign it from a real person. A name and a phone number make it easy to reply or call.

Resist the urge to add photos of every property, a newsletter, and three calls to action. One property, one link, one clear next step.

Make Rebooking Direct Easier Than the OTA

Outreach only works if booking direct is easy once the guest clicks. A few things to check:

  • Real-time availability. If your site shows dates that are actually booked, you lose trust fast. Your booking website should pull availability directly from your reservation system. See our guide to vacation rental website templates for what to check.
  • Mobile booking that works. Most guests will open your email on a phone. Test the full booking flow on one.
  • Your website in every guest message. Include a link to your site in confirmations, pre-arrival messages, and post-stay follow-ups, so guests see it before they ever need it. Our vacation rental guest communication guide covers which messages to automate.
  • Clear, honest pricing. If your direct price ends up higher than the OTA price after fees, guests notice. Make sure the direct option is at least as good.

A direct booking website connected to your reservation system handles most of this for you, since availability, rates, and guest details stay in one place.

How Do You Know It's Working?

Track a few simple numbers each year so you can see whether repeat guests are moving direct:

  • Repeat guest rate: the share of this year's reservations from guests who stayed before.
  • Direct share of repeat bookings: of those repeat guests, how many booked direct instead of through an OTA.
  • Fees avoided: repeat direct bookings multiplied by the OTA fee you would have paid. This is the number owners care about.
  • Email response: how many past guests clicked and how many booked within 60 days of your outreach.

Even moving a handful of repeat guests direct each year compounds. Those guests tend to keep booking direct once they've done it once. For more on growing booking volume overall, see how to increase vacation rental bookings, and for how new guests find your site through AI search, read our post on answer engine optimization for vacation rentals. Repeat guests are also a big part of scaling a vacation rental management company without scaling your marketing spend at the same rate.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I email guests who booked through Airbnb to invite them back directly?

Generally, no. Airbnb's policies restrict using guest contact details from an Airbnb booking for marketing outside the platform, and other OTAs have similar rules. Check the current terms for each channel. Focus your outreach on guests who booked direct and opted in to hear from you.

When is the best time to contact past vacation rental guests?

The holidays and early January work well, since many families plan summer trips then. Reaching out before your peak weeks fill, or a few months before the anniversary of a guest's last stay, also works.

Should I offer repeat guests a discount for booking direct?

It can help, but it doesn't have to be a discount. Holding their preferred week, early check-in, or a waived fee often works just as well. Make sure any perk fits your owner agreements.

How do I track how many repeat guests book direct?

Look at this year's reservations from returning guests and compare how many came through your website or phone versus an OTA. Multiply the direct ones by the OTA fee you would have paid to see what the program is worth.

See How RNS Supports Direct Bookings

RNS direct booking websites pull availability and rates straight from your reservation system, so past guests can rebook on your site without the OTA. Book a demo to see how it works.

Schedule a demo

Join our community of hundreds of customers who trust RNS as their rental management platform.

Schedule a demo

Join our community of hundreds of customers who trust RNS as their rental management platform.